Law College

A state enacted a statute to provide financial aid for residents of the state who attend public or private colleges and universities in the state. Under this statute, eligible students receive varying amounts of money, depending on need. A student living in the state who has never paid taxes applied for a grant of funds under this statute to attend a private college in a different state. His application was denied because the college was outside of his home state. The student filed suit in federal court against the appropriate state official, challenging the constitutionality of the denial on equal protection grounds and to compel the granting of his application. Which of the following statements is most correct?


a. the student has standing to maintain the action despite the fact that he never paid taxes in state.

b. The student has standing. A person challenging the constitutionality of a government action must have standing to raise the issue. To have standing, a person must show that he is injured by a government action (injury in fact) and that a favorable decision will eliminate the harm.

c. Generally, a taxpayer does not have standing to challenge the way tax money is spent because any alleged injury is too remote.

d. However, here the student is not bringing suit as a taxpayer; rather he is alleging that the state policy of providing financial aid only for residents who attend schools in the state injures him by depriving him of such aid solely on the basis of attending a college outside the state, thus violating his right to equal protection. A ruling in the student's favor will eliminate the harm to him. Therefore, the student has a concrete stake in the outcome of this controversy, entirely independent of whether he has ever paid taxes in the state.

Answers

Answer 1

The most correct statement is option d. The student has standing to maintain the action despite never having paid taxes in the state. The student is not bringing the suit as a taxpayer but is challenging the state's policy on equal protection grounds, alleging that it violates his right to equal protection by denying him financial aid solely based on attending a college outside the state.

Standing refers to a person's legal right to bring a lawsuit and challenge a government action. Generally, a person must show that they have suffered an injury in fact and that a favorable decision will remedy the harm. In this case, although the student has never paid taxes in the state, he is not suing as a taxpayer. Instead, he is asserting a violation of his right to equal protection under the law.

The student's claim is based on the state's policy of providing financial aid only to residents who attend schools in the state. By denying him financial aid solely based on attending a college outside the state, the student argues that his right to equal protection is being violated. If the court rules in his favor, it would eliminate the harm he is experiencing, as he would be eligible for financial aid despite attending an out-of-state college. Therefore, the student has a concrete stake in the outcome of the case, irrespective of whether he has paid taxes in the state.

Learn more about lawsuit  here

brainly.com/question/32266950

#SPJ11

Related Questions

Rufus is playing soccer with his friends after school. rufus pushes samantha while chasing the soccer ball as part of the game. samantha falls and sprains her wrist. rufus also intentionally kicks bethany while she is lying on the ground after a play has finished. rufus was mad that she had scored a goal on him earlier in the game. alex yells at rufus to get himself under control, and rufus responds by trying to punch alex with a closed fist. who can and cannot bring a successful lawsuit against rufus for battery? how about assault? please define the torts of assault and battery in your answer.

Answers

In this scenario, the torts of assault and battery are involved. Assault refers to the intentional act of causing apprehension or fear of harmful or offensive contact in another person.

Battery, on the other hand, involves the intentional and harmful or offensive physical contact with another person without their consent.Based on the information provided, Samantha, Bethany, and Alex can potentially bring a successful lawsuit against Rufus for both assault and battery.Samantha can bring a successful lawsuit against Rufus for battery because he intentionally pushed her, causing her to fall and sprain her wrist. This constitutes harmful physical contact without her consent.Bethany can also bring a successful lawsuit against Rufus for battery because he intentionally kicked her while she was lying on the ground. Again, this constitutes harmful physical contact without her consent.


Alex, on the other hand, can bring a successful lawsuit against Rufus for assault but not battery. When Rufus tried to punch Alex, he caused apprehension or fear of harmful or offensive contact. However, since Rufus did not make actual physical contact with Alex, battery is not applicable.It's important to note that the success of these lawsuits may vary depending on the jurisdiction and other factors. It's advisable for the parties involved to consult with a legal professional for accurate advice specific to their situation.

To know more about apprehension visit:
https://brainly.com/question/32224854?
#SPJ11

When hcps use a cpt code for a more expensive service than performed this is example of

Answers

When healthcare providers use a Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) code for a more expensive service than the one actually performed, it is an example of upcoding.

Upcoding refers to the practice of assigning a CPT code that represents a higher-cost or more complex service than what was actually performed. This practice can occur intentionally or inadvertently and may result in higher reimbursement rates or increased charges for the provided services. Healthcare providers may engage in upcoding for various reasons, such as maximizing reimbursement or inflating the perceived complexity of a procedure to justify higher charges. However, it is important to note that upcoding is considered fraudulent and unethical.

By using a CPT code that does not accurately reflect the service provided, healthcare providers may receive higher reimbursement from insurance companies or government programs. This can lead to financial gain for the provider at the expense of the payer, whether it is an insurance company or a government healthcare program. Hence, when healthcare providers use a CPT code for a more expensive service than the one performed, it is an example of upcoding, which is considered fraudulent and unethical.

Learn more about Current Procedural Terminology here:

https://brainly.com/question/28296339

#SPJ11

Can i get a permit without taking the drivers education class in north carolina?

Answers

I think you meant Drivers license because you do not need the drivers education class for the permit. Depending on your age you will need to take you Drivers ED or wait a certain period of time before you get your license. But you will need to get you permit before you are allowed to take a drivers class

which classification of scrutiny would be appropriate for a court to use to examine a state law regulating the price of milk. choose 2 answer choices.

Answers

Hello! When examining a state law regulating the price of milk, two classification of scrutiny that could be appropriate for a court to use are rational basis scrutiny and intermediate scrutiny.

1. Rational basis scrutiny: This is the lowest level of scrutiny and is typically used for cases involving economic or social welfare regulations. Under rational basis scrutiny, the court will uphold the law if it is rationally related to a legitimate government interest. In the case of a state law regulating the price of milk, if the law is shown to have a reasonable connection to a legitimate government interest, such as ensuring affordable access to milk for consumers, it is likely to be upheld.
2. Intermediate scrutiny: This level of scrutiny is used for cases involving laws that discriminate based on gender or illegitimate classifications. If a state law regulating the price of milk is found to treat different groups of individuals differently, such as favoring certain milk producers over others, the court may apply intermediate scrutiny. Under this standard, the law must be substantially related to an important government interest in order to be upheld.

Please note that the specific classification of scrutiny that would be applied may depend on the jurisdiction and specific circumstances of the case. It is always best to consult legal experts or refer to relevant case law for accurate and up-to-date information.

To know more about scrutiny visit:
https://brainly.com/question/33134065
#SPJ11

Other Questions
what remediation will the technician perform? group of answer choices quarantine infected items. boot into safe mode. perform os reinstallation. remove registry items. Children who have been given specific training in social-emotional skills are taught how to? The average no-load voltage in a dc arc welding circuit is ____ volts. a. 10b. 20 15c. 30 60d. 80 1540 Hz ac source, a 40- resistor, a 0.30-h inductor, and a 60-f capacitor. the rms current in the circuit is measured to be 1.6 a. what is the power factor of the circuit? M Review. student holds a tuning fork oscillating at 256 Hz. He walks toward a wall at a constant speed of 1.33 m/s. (a) What beat frequency does he observe between the tuning fork and its echo? Study of human behavior in its natural context, involving observation of behavior and physical setting is_________ research. A. ethnographic research B. experimental research C. pilot research D. MRA E. none of the above A complex fraud that involves the purchase and subsequent resale of property at greatly inflated prices is called? Other things equal, an increase in the u.s. net capital outflow ________ the demand for loanable funds and ________ the supply of dollars in the market for foreign currency exchange. What will be the result of executing the following code? int[] x = {0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5}; Question Content AreaOn June 1, $40,000 of treasury bonds were purchased between interest dates. The brokerage commission was $600. The bonds pay interest at 12%, which is paid semiannually on January 1 and July 1. How much interest revenue will be recorded on July 1 Directions: The following passage is written in a point of view that does not support the writers goals. Help the writer by selecting a better point of view. The paragraph is part of an American History paper.Benjamin Franklin is my favorite American founding father. I had no idea he was such a prolific inventor! This term, we read that he is credited with inventing lightning rods, a glass harmonica, and bifocal glasses.What would be a better point of view for this passage?a) First personb) Third personc) Second person A 300.0 mL quantity of hydrogen is collected over water at 19.5 C and a total atmospheric pressure of 750. mm Hg. The partial pressure of water at this temperature is 17.0 mm Hg 3. to decide whether the rain and the bus running late are dependent or independent events, first define the two events and then write their probabilities as decimals. (3 points) When using idle for python programming, what color is used to distinguish built-in function names? The ________ the down payment made by a borrower when taking out a mortgage, the ________. Which description does not function as a metaphor that could be used to describe cultural stimuli? O fungos, no passado ,ja foram considerados plantas. entretanto, alguma caracteristicas permitem diferencia-los dos vegetais .sobre os reinos fungi ee plantae marque a alternativa correta Find the sum of the measures of the interior angles of each convex polygon.18-gon When a customer returns merchandise that it recently purchased on credit, the journal entry to record this transaction would credit Accounts Receivable and the Cost of Goods Sold. It would also debit: 1. Sales Returns the nurse plans to maintain hydration for the client at risk for thrombus formation. what evaluation finding is an indicator that the intervention is successful?